| 1 | While shepherds watched their flocks by night | Michael Beesly | 4:35 | 
| 2 | Let an anthem of praise | [anonymous] / Caleb Ashworth | 4:35 | 
| 3 | While shepherds watched their flocks by night | John Christopher Smith / John Arnold | 3:06 | 
| 4 | Pastorale (Concerto in E-flat, op. 3/4) | Pieter Hellendaal | 3:35 | 
| 5 | Hark! how all the welkin rings | [anonymous] / Thomas Butts | 6:24 | 
| 6 | Hush! my dear, lie still and slumber | [anonymous] / Thomas Butts | 4:08 | 
| 7 | As shepherds watched their fleecy care | Joseph Key | 6:15 | 
| 8 | Hark! the herald angels sing | Samuel Arnold | 3:34 | 
| 9 | While shepherds watched their flock by night (Cranbrook) | Thomas Clark | 5:04 | 
| 10 | Hark! the herald angels sing (Georgia) | George Frideric Handel / Edward Miller | 4:08 | 
| 11 | There were shepherds abiding in the field | Thomas Jarman | 3:22 | 
| 12 | Rondo on "God rest ye merry, Gentlemen" | Samuel Wesley | 6:18 | 
| 13 | Angels from the realms of glory | William Matthews | 5:24 | 
| 14 | Hymning seraphs wake the morning | George Frideric Handel / Thomas Taylor | 3:01 | 
| 15 | While shepherds watched their flocks by night | John Foster | 4:48 |