| 1 | I Saw Three Ships / O Tannenbaum / Allon, Gay, Gay Bergeres / The Holly and the Ivy | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 7:55 |
| 2 | Fum, Fum, Fum / Hacia Belen / Ya Viene La Vieja / La Virgen Lava Panales | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 5:53 |
| 3 | The Cherry Tree Carol / Mary Had a Baby / So Blest a Sight | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 8:58 |
| 4 | How Unto Bethlehem / A Virgin Unspotted / The Twelve Days of Christmas | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 6:44 |
| 5 | Good King Wenceslas / The Boar's Head Carol / Christ Was Born on Christmas Day / How Far Is It to Bethlehem? | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 7:41 |
| 6 | March of the Kings / Here, Mid the Ass and Oxen / Touro-Louro-Louro | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 6:05 |
| 7 | Carol of the Birds / O Magnum Mysterium | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 7:36 |
| 8 | What Child Is This / Masters in This Hall / Break Forth, O Beauteous Heav'nly Light | Robert Shaw conducts the Robert Shaw Chorale | 6:03 |